Buggeyes
A Friend
Mormon God-Adam Theory
Nighthawk wrote:
QUOTE |
Or, as I suspect is the case, he has sought and received revelation on it, and knows that it is a matter for each person to get their own revelation on, so he must keep it strictly sacred...
This seems to me to be one of the most sacred of subjects. That is, real knowledge about it would ONLY come through revelation. |
and erdoch wrote:
QUOTE |
I too believe that the Adam God doctrine is a very sacred one that should not be triffled with. |
My understanding is that nothing is too sacred to talk openly about, except when it comes to those things spoken of in the temple, and in that case, we can talk openly about those things IN THE TEMPLE. There are, of course, things that are unlawful to speak, such as those things which the Three Nephites heard and saw and were prohibited from saying, but other than that, church doctrine can and should be openly discussed. If not, such "sacred" matters are really just "secret doctrines" and we know that the Lord works not in secret or in darkness, but the evil one does.
The simple fact that is has been claimed that Brigham Young preached this doctrine openly shows that this thing isn't as sacred as each of you claim it is. All of the doctrine of Christ is sacred and important to our salvation, but we nevertheless seek to get all men to understand it and we do so openly.
Let me ask the two of you, is the Adam-God theory within the bounds of the scriptures, outside of the bounds of the scriptures or contrary to the scriptures? By within the bounds of the scriptures, I mean that the scriptures themselves do promote this doctrine, do explain it, expound it, teach it, preach it. By outside the bounds of the scriptures, I mean that the scriptures speak nothing concerning this doctrine, one way or the other, whether to its condemnation or approbation. In other words, the scriptures are silent about it and the acceptance of this doctrine does not directly or indirectly contradict the doctrine found in the scriptures. By contrary to the scriptures, I mean that the scriptures condemn such a theory either directly or indirectly; that either they speak against the theory or that the theory is completely incompatible with the revealed doctrine of Christ as found in the Standard Works.
So, what do each of you say? Is the Adam-God theory within, outside or contrary to the scriptures?
Please do present scriptural evidence to support whichever view you take. We all can profess belief in this and that, but belief alone doesn't cut it. A well-intentioned, incorrect belief will just as much lead us from the true path as evil intent. I think it was Brigham Young himself that said that "the road to hell is paved with good intentions."