Name: Brick
Country:
Comments: Happy_LDS- Read the definition of a "prophet" in the Old testament of the Bible. If everything he
says comes true, he is a prophet, if one thing fails, he is a false prophet, and he is to be stoned to death. Joseph actually should have been stoned before he got shot. Prophets may be just
"men", but sometimes, like Brigham Young, they wield unquestioned authority for a while. It is definitely a place of power that can be abused.
I don't believe in the infallibility of prophets. Also you compare everything to the Bible which is good but as LDS people we also believe in other books of scripture as well as modern revelation. But I understand what you're saying, what I am trying to say is not everything a prophet speaks is considered doctrine.
This is of course a touchy topic. Even Pres. Joseph Fielding Smith suggested we forget about this topic. However, Pres. B. Young talked very plainly about this. Said he in a sermon delivered on April 9, 1852: Now hear it, O inhabitants of the earth, Jew and Gentile, Saint and sinner! When our father Adam came into the garden of Eden, he came into it with a celestial body, and brought Eve, one of his wives, with him.
So, when Pres. B. Young started out with "Now hear it,. .. Is not the voice of uncertainty, but spoken as one having authority. President Smith states that Pres. Young was not properly quoted, which makes no sense as this talk was given in a full tabernacle. The disagreement between the two is not that of the fact that Adam and Eve were created on another earth, but more over the fact that Pres. Young sees Adam as God the Father and above Jesus while Pres. Smith sees Jesus above Adam and does not see Adam as THE Heavenly Father but as a person that reached Godhood. Big Big difference. The earlier endowmend sessions clearly identify Adam as God the Father as did Heber C. Kimball, John Taylor, W. Woodruff, Orson Pratt etc etc. To me this whole issues is clearly embarresing to our move towards more acceptable Christianity. Like becoming part of the rest of the Christian world.
Brick said