I do not think we should put them in the underground room at all. I say we tie them up sitting them in the middle of the drive with the stolen money at their feet so the police find them and the money. This will help us look a bit better. But we will be gone but not for long.
The shifter will go get his car and bring it around to the main drive so we will be ready to drive off once we get the thugs where they need to be. We can give Felipe a nice burial out in the woods.
In Character: "OK we had enough with these creeps, let's get moving now." Assassin checks their knots to make sure they aren't going to escape.
In Character: Assassin, "So long guys, the police and ambulance will be here shortly to take you on the rest of this adventure. Now if I were you I would keep shut about us and just tell them about your 'sins'".
Assassin grins and then makes his way to Shifter's car.
In Character: Krusten is glad this is over. She gets the money bags and puts them near to the robbers so the police find it with them.
Out of Character: We forgot about the money. Also, we are supposed to get a reward out of this? Maybe we should call the news media first so we can be sure the police do the honest thing.