Close Topic Options

Night Sky

Night Sky

Rate the below art piece on a scale of 1-10 and talk about the reasons for your rating:

Sky Night

I'll give it an 8. It's a nice piece, the light effect was pretty well done although I remain unconvinced about the moon, the person could have done a better job with it.

Night Sky UFO & Writing Art Education Sciences

Well, I hope this isn't one of JB's originals.

I have to give this one a '5'. It isn't bad, but it isn't great either. I get no emotional impact from it. I wouldn't put it up as wallpaper on my computer. I don't care if I ever see it again, or anything like it. But, I am not repelled by it either.

It is interesting how the light effects are shown, but I don't get any sort of feeling for what it is, or really even where it comes from. The moon and stars are OK, but that is it.

The best thing about the picture is the landscape, which is quite well done.

Sky Night

I would give it about a 4. The idea behind it is great, but as Nighthawk said, I got no emotion out of it. I felt like I should be feeling the light coming towards me, but I didn't. It's almost done in a too rigid fashion. I agree with LDS about the moon, it just doesn't quite make me think realistically about it. I think if there was more natural of the light, it could evoke more emotion. Like I said, the idea behind the work is great.

I think what impresses me the most is the gradual light change in the sky. It goes from lighter to darker as it climbs higher, and it does so in a fluid manner.

Sky Night

No it isn't, but even if it was the comments should still be open.

I agree with most of you here about this painting and would add that its' biggest problem is the light dispersing into the darkness. The artist makes the light too solid as though it were a branch or onion growing / reaching.

The rest of the painting is not bad.

I give it a 6.