I suppose a lot of this debate boils down to what exactly is free speech, and a topic that we have on this very forum: "Why Do People Become Offended?" We even have a personality quiz: "How thin is your skin?"
My first post in this thread predicted that Imus would fall, and it happened because, as Vincenzo pointed out, enough people complained. Whenever the feeding frenzy of the media begins, you can pretty much see which way the wind blows.
I've never listened to the shock jocks or hardcore comedy (of any color) because I find it offensive, not amusing. But there are plenty of people who do find it amusing, or these types of so-called "entertainment" wouldn't ever make it to the airwaves - let alone have paying sponsors.
Probably much worse things have been said publicly, but if no one complains, there's no problem? It's all about perspective and WHO gets offended.
International Level: Ambassador / Political Participation: 595 59.5%
I will be honest. When I heard the comment made by Don Imus, I felt annoyed but I was not sure what he meant. Somehow, I knew that it was a racial slur and when my spouse explained it to me, I became incensed. Why do Americans abuse their "freedom of speech?" I do not agree with changing the station or the channel, if you do not like listening to the comments made by these shock jocks. This is simply not good enough for me. This is why the world is clearly divided today. Some races think they are superior to others and therefore believe that there is nothing wrong with making racial slurs, when referring to other races who they deem as "inferior." This is not right. People are human beings and not dogs or objects. Saying these ugly words are hurtful, cruel and uncalled for. I suppose Don Imus felt he had a right to consider the Rutgers "Nappy Headed Hos" since they qualified for the championship game and were playing against a team that was considered "the best." But then again, these shock jocks are not well educated and therefore feel compelled to drag others down (especially when an "inferior race" is involved) to make themselves feel superior. But is it necessary for these shock jocks to advertise their ignorance so openly on the airwaves?
Hats off to CBS for firing Don Imus! A brilliant move even though it was borne out of pressure from the masses.
International Level: New Activist / Political Participation: 14 1.4%
I disagree on some of your points Geenie so don't disappear and let's enter a debate!
QUOTE |
When I heard the comment made by Don Imus, I felt annoyed but I was not sure what he meant. |
QUOTE |
Why do Americans abuse their "freedom of speech?" |
QUOTE |
Some races think they are superior to others and therefore believe that there is nothing wrong with making racial slurs, when referring to other races who they deem as "inferior." But then again, these shock jocks are not well educated and therefore feel compelled to drag others down (especially when an "inferior race" is involved) |
International Level: International Guru / Political Participation: 1089 100%
LDS I am laughing at the first line of your post and I will playfully respond "your wish is my command!" I will stay and debate on this issue with you!
QUOTE |
When I heard the comment made by Don Imus, I felt annoyed but I was not sure what he meant. |
QUOTE |
What do you mean by you did not know what he meant? His comment was very clear. |
QUOTE |
Why do Americans abuse their "freedom of speech?" |
QUOTE |
Some races think they are superior to others and therefore believe that there is nothing wrong with making racial slurs, when referring to other races who they deem as "inferior." |
QUOTE |
But then again, these shock jocks are not well educated and therefore feel compelled to drag others down (especially when an "inferior race" is involved) |
QUOTE |
You cannot get angry at a guy (that happens to be white) because he called "nappy-headed hos" to a group of women when themselves call each other worst things like the "N" word or listen and dance to the vibes of hip-hop which are known to degrade women and races. Is it because he is white that they are so angry about? YES! |
Rather off topic, but... Tonight, there was a report about Don Imus having a meeting with the ladies, to offer a personal apology to them. At least some good came out of this! |
International Level: New Activist / Political Participation: 14 1.4%
Geenie, let me start by saying is good to see you debating! You should "attack" (no pun intended) the Trini board where we have many controversial topics you haven't replied as yet, a lot of them related to race too.
First of all, let me start by saying that I am NOT defending, justifying or rationalizing what Imus said. I think he was very wrong and has been wrong for a very long time, neither I am blaming the girls of the basketball team at all who are the victims of the situation but I DO blame some of the African American community who DO listen hip-hop and rap, who DANCE to this music and they are suddenly shocked and "offended" by what Imus said. Those are the ones I am speaking about. It does NOT change the fact that what Imus said is wrong, nevertheless those African Americans that I am speaking about should not dare to say anything while they are fully consciously supporting that type of crap-talk through music.
QUOTE |
I agree with you when you mentioned about stopping this "post traumatic slavery mentality" but how are we supposed to stop, it if it is constantly being perpetuated as a fact of life? |
QUOTE |
A member stated that comedians like Chris Rocke and Dave La Chapelle are guilty of saying things worse than what Don Imus said. And yet no one comments on this. Yes this is true. But please remember that people like Chris Rocke are talking from experience. This is how we learn more about the world when we share it with others. In life we have positive and negative experiences. The positive experiences are sometimes very few but very uplifting. And the negative experiences can be ugly, traumatic and profound. Chris Rocke once shared his experience about how he was judged and poorly treated, in the entertainment world not for his talent but because of his race. But did he allow this to deter him from living his dream? No! Instead, he chose to share it with others in a jocular fashion. Racism is no laughing matter. But Chris Rocke chose to communicate his negative experiences to others, as a way of raising awareness of the ills in society and also to profit from it too! |
QUOTE |
Of course you can become angry for what the guy said. Why? Because it is morally wrong. How do you know that these ladies also listen to hip hop music? Why can't they appreciate classical music? Don't you think you are stereotyping these ladies? |
International Level: International Guru / Political Participation: 1089 100%
Just adding a general comment here.
So, Don Imus has been fired. Yeah, I agree that he was completely out of line in his comments.
However, he was saying EXACTLY the same thing that black men all over the US are saying. I have PERSONALLY heard black young men say that about black young women.
I don't believe that Mr. Imus' comments were racist. He was trying, in my opinion, to sound like a young black man. Stupid. He should have known well that it is "one rule for me, another for you." Racial relations in the US are filled with double standards.
International Level: International Guru / Political Participation: 854 85.4%
Imus is out - what about the others?
Amid all his apologizing and genuflecting and begging forgiveness from the college girls he insulted, shock jock Don Imus, fired by CBS and MSNBC last week for inappropriate comments on the air, couldn't stop himself from one moment of clarity and self-defense when he called out America's media, as well as critics such as Al Sharpton, for using double standards.
"The hypocrisy is absurd," he said.
I'm not defending Imus for calling members of the Rutgers women's basketball team "nappy-headed hos."
Neither, for that matter, is he.
Ref. https://deseretnews.com/dn/view/0,1249,660211969,00.html
Oh dear! After reading the above post, I suppose it would be safe to say Don Imus' apology was not sincere after all. Isn't it amazing the things we do when under a tremendous amount of pressure? I guess his "apology" can be labelled in two words, "damage control."
International Level: New Activist / Political Participation: 14 1.4%