JB, if my chracter goes to the doctor to heal him, does that mean my character's HP is fully restored after paying the doctor to heal him? First Bruconero said that John's HP should be already full and Play By Post agree with him, but you said JB, that my chracter needs to rest in order to gain any HP, so far, John rested for 1 night, but didn't increased my character's HP? How long exactly it takes for John to revive his HP to 11 again?
You pay 5 gps for each HP you need restored. In your case that was 25 gps. For those 5 HP you would have needed 35 days to recover fully. In the story, I said this: "Time heals wounds..." In other words I did not give a set time from when you returned from the South to the time you met up with the new Characters so we will assume you at least had 35 days to recover. In all you do have your full HP now which is 11.
JB, I posted my intention to hit the thug, well, on his private parts, when he just arrived but you said he stepped back without any harm so I supposed my attempt was in vain. Should I roll for that action?
I don't know if you were able to hit him yet or not that's why I need your combat rolls. Once you give me that I can continue the Scenario. As a general rule anytime you wish to perform any kind of attack then you will need to roll the Combat Dice.
The basics of it can be read here: Source 3 however if you did not use it or seek medical attention immediately I could start penalizing your character.
If the herbs are used in conjunction with adequate rest then you could begin healing, but it a slow approach and it should not be seen as some sort of of healing potion.
Using healing herbs on an unconscious character can restore them to 1 HP only with rest.