The best way to rate a movie, in my opinion, is to take out the brand value. For instance if this movie wasn't labelled "Star Wars" in it would it be just as good or is the "Star Wars" in it making you like it? I see it as a good movie but nothing wow. It didn't leave me feeling sorry or connected with the characters I felt like it if it was a big stage play.
I enjoyed the movie and I guess that's my rating system. The fact that is was Star Wars made it a bit more enjoyable for me because it dealt with some aspects of the very first Star Wars movie in a way that I thought was believable. I won't ruin it for anyone who hasn't seen the movie but the ending for me was spot on.