data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5978e/5978e8203440481250d7809668b0a8e1122b3a0c" alt=">"
I've always wondered how the blacksmiths was able to come up with these combinations of metal, was it just centuries of testing?
International Level: Junior Politician / Political Participation: 71 7.1%
I think you are right Fairmaiden just trial and error along with knowledge passed master to apprentice. I know I have some chisels my grandfather forged and I can not buy one with the same properties. I have cut through bolts that bought chisels just broke on.
Mine where made from the frame of a model t-ford then pounded and annealed it took hours to make one. Metallurgy is very fascinating. My grandfather stopped smithing when he could not buy high quality coal anymore.
International Level: Senior Politician / Political Participation: 188 18.8%
Lucky you. If my granddad did that I would be right there forging with him! I know the Japanese are well known for their swords because it could both bend, cut and remained very strong. I don't know if it was any comparison to how the Europeans did it.
International Level: Junior Politician / Political Participation: 71 7.1%
I do not think so as the samurai sword was folded many times (20 or so I think) The shape of the blade is also important as that is what absorbs the impact of the blow. The folding also built strength and ability to hold a keen edge.
Japan built swords to cut were when fighting one in full steel armour the sword really was dull and was used as a club to dent the armour so the knight could not move. Then the page would run along with the knight and stab the fallen knights in the face through the helmet or in the back of the neck.
Given the two extremes it is hard to compare the blades. Even the dueling swords were rapiers which is more of a stabbing then chopping or slicing tool.
Yes I like knives in all shapes.
International Level: Senior Politician / Political Participation: 188 18.8%