In my opinion you cannot over dress for the sacrament, unless it is loud, but as you said it wasn't, so the Bishop should allow this. As was mentioned before this is a policy thing. I will not go into it here - it is better covered in the LDS Mature Board: Policy / Commandments. The only real mention of the importance of wearing a white shirt was when Elder Holland gave a talk on it in General Conference some years ago (Search LDS.org), but even he admitted that there is nothing that says we have to wear a white shirt.
To show how Branch Presidents and Bishops can make this a non issue all you have to do is follow what some of them do: Keep extra white shirts and ties in the office, that way if someone does not meet the 'policy' you can simply give him the attire so he can.
Other than what has already been said I hope that helps.
Here is the quote of Elder Holland about white shirts:
QUOTE |
May I suggest that wherever possible a white shirt be worn by the deacons, teachers, and priests who handle the sacrament. For sacred ordinances in the Church we often use ceremonial clothing, and a white shirt could be seen as a gentle reminder of the white clothing you wore in the baptismal font and an anticipation of the white shirt you will soon wear into the temple and onto your missions. That simple suggestion is not intended to be pharisaic or formalistic. We do not want deacons or priests in uniforms or unduly concerned about anything but the purity of their lives. But how our young people dress can teach a holy principle to us all, and it certainly can convey sanctity. As President David O. McKay taught, a white shirt contributes to the sacredness of the holy sacrament (see Conference Report, Oct. 1956, p. 89). |
Hello, new here and just wanting to make a comment. I do agree that we need to keep a reverant standard in Church. However, to actually believe that you have to have certain clothing on to bless the sacrament is a bit overboard. I have blessed the sacrament wearing a sweater and no tie. I really don't think we should make something like this into a big issue as all it will do is alientate -- nobody gets positively excited about white shirts, but quite a few can get turned off.
QUOTE |
I really don't think we should make something like this into a big issue as all it will do is alientate... |
I just worry that this can be an issue to some people. Personally, I don't think a white shirt or not makes us more spiritual or not (I mean really, Isaiah preached to Israel naked for three years). I attended a seminar in Russia and while there met a professor who made it a point that he has held many positions in his ward and stake but is upfront that he will never wear a tie. He was quite intellectual and really was a non-conformist (converted from conservative Judaism as a young man). I would have enjoyed having him as my high priest quorum teacher.
Message Edited... Persephone: It is not necessary to quote the entire post of the user above you. See Constructive Posting Policy. |
Fiannan said:
QUOTE |
Personally, I don't think a white shirt or not makes us more spiritual or not |
QUOTE |
I attended a seminar in Russia and while there met a professor who made it a point that he has held many positions in his ward and stake but is upfront that he will never wear a tie. He was quite intellectual and really was a non-conformist |
QUOTE (Fiannan) |
I just worry that this can be an issue to some people. |
Personally I do not wear white shirts to church. The reason being because I just prefer color shirts. I like color. White gets dirty easily when I wear them and I just prefer color. I do not look at it as an excuse but rather my personal preference. I do wear a tie because I like them for the most part, but I have been known to not wear a tie from time to time to church. My councilor in my elders quorum does not wear a white shirt. (or a collared one at that) And I am ok with that. He is a great man I am glad that such things did refrain me from hearing the Lord's revelation to call him. I do pass the sacrament from time to time in my colored shirt if called upon. I wear a white shirt in the temple when doing ordinance work, but I usually wear a colored shirt to the temple. Its not a personal crusade for me to push my colored shirt on to everyone else, really I never think about this topic much. Personally I have a lot more to worry about in my progression then a white shirt. It seems to me to be a cultural thing, I really do not feel that Jesus demands me to wear a white shirt regardless who is in charge.