Close Topic Options

Am I A Good Poster?

We have a Charisma point system in the forum. For detailed questions check the FAQ board. This section is for comments only.

Basically a user may read a member's post and if they thought it was very enlightening or beneficial then they click on the '+' to give a positive rating or if they felt the post was against forum rules or very bad then they give a '-'. The user can then make a comment about why they gave a negative or positive point to the user's Charisma.

Question is...

What does a member have to post in order for you to give a positive charisma point?

Poster Good I Am

I give points to any user that posts constructively. Their post does not necessarily have to benefit me, but if I know it will benefit someone else I will give a point for effort, especially if they have no points or few points. This way I know the user feels appreciated for their effort.

If a user has over a 100 points I do not give anymore unless it is something exceptional, moving, or ground breaking

If the user has a high post count but under a hundred then the post has to be well placed.

So in the end I guess if it is a new user I will give liberally, but if it is a veteran user then they have to come good.

Am I A Good Poster? Feedback & FAQ News Community

In the past I haven't been too generous with the Charisma points because... well.. frankly, I didn't really think about it much. Now that we are growing so fast, I'm trying to do better when I see a good post or someone greeting our newcomers frequently, I am adding to their points.

And I still get a smile when someone gives me points

Roz

Poster Good I Am

I like the idea behind the charisma points and look at mine everyday to see if they have gone up/down. I have been more cautious of giving them out as well because I know how happy I feel when I get one. Very good system that I have not seen on any other forum!

Poster Good I Am

I also like the whole idea of charisma points. While I am not as diligent about handing them out as others are, I have recently been trying to be a little more generous, and pay attention to the thought and effort involved in creating a good post.

My only complaint is that the associated comments with charisma points are so small (60 characters).

Am I A Good Poster?

The reason for this is that all that information is stored, that is a lot of info to keep for one member, so the smaller the better. I have found that using key words is better, just as a teacher would if correcting a paper, for example:
wrong: I liked it a lot because it brought tears to my eyes
better: Very thought provoking and moving

Am I Good Poster

I LOVE the charisma point feature. I check mine regularly and I'm grateful to all of those posters who have gave me charisma points in the past. I think it really makes your self-esteem grow a little more

Am I Good Poster Community News FAQ & Feedback

I sometimes wish some of my other regular forums had this feature, but if they did it would likely be abused. I could see too many folks using it just to make someone look bad- not cool! (could a user end up with negative charisma points?) Or it could be used like just another clique-ish popularity contest. No thank you.

Anyway, we're talking about our beloved Borde! Some folks make so many wonderful posts, but there's the restriction of only being able to change a members' charisma once every 72 hours. Oh well... So be it.