
The US immigration authorities do NOT believe that they have a good program. They don't WANT any sort of system to stop illegal immigration. That is why the subject is under such intense discussion in the United States. There is hardly any system at all in place to stop illegal immigration right now.
Most people in the US want us to enforce our borders. This subject transcends political party. There are those on the far left who don't want us to do so. There are also some on the right who don't care. However, I think there is something like 70 to 80% of US citizens, including legal immigrants and their children (grandchildren, etc.) who want the borders tightly enforced. Many of us also want increased legal immigration.
Right now, though, it is very easy for anyone who wants to get into the US to do so. What is very difficult is for someone who wants to move here legally to do so.
I would personally prefer that the borders be tight as drums. Then, go through and make huge fines for any business that hires illegal immigrants. Finally, every person who is found to be in the country illegally should be immediately deported, unless they have committed crimes here, besides the crime of entering the country illegally. Those who have committed other crimes here should be punished accordingly, preferably with harsher punishments due to the fact that they are already criminals.
But President Bush, along with several organizations, doesn't want that. He wants amnesty for somewhere near 30 million illegal immigrants. He also wants to make it much easier for future illegals to become legal.
It is a huge problem, and the easy solutions are not palatable to the majority of US citizens.
International Level: International Guru / Political Participation: 854 85.4%
I'm beginning to think that there isn't a man or woman in the government that can really come up with a decent plan for securing our borders that will really work. Its either to lenient, or to harsh. We need to secure our borders but still allow immigration freely in our country. After all, we were all immigrants at one point unless you are a Native American. Kicking out people just wanting to feed their families seems a little to harsh for me. And I honestly don't believe that illegals are making a real impact on our economy, at least not negatively. But I suppose its a matter of opinion because they don't have any real stats, just guestimates.
POLICE ORDERED TO REPORT ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT ARRESTS TO FEDS
New Jersey law enforcement was ordered Wednesday to notify federal immigration officials whenever someone arrested for an indictable offense or drunken driving is determined to be an illegal immigrant.
Ref. https://www.cnn.com/2007/US/08/22/newark.I'm...n.ap/index.html
I have noticed that ICE has been picking up enforcement. Employers are starting to notice. (It's about time.)
In my view, the way the U.S. and state governments have ignored the violation of our immigration laws for so long has allowed Americans to take in Hispanics almost as slave labor. We create a permanent underclass (though the illegal immigrants are willing, of course).
Recently a class in a Catholic school tried to address the issue. Some students objected to the discussion, arguing that illegal immigration was wrong. They were asked to be quiet, and at the end one student changed, "White power" several times.
Funny thing is, similar change by Hispanic groups have been made at rallies supporting illegal immigrants. You don't hear much about that.
Either is wrong.
https://www.9news.com/news/top-article.aspx?storyid=76418
Tortdog:
QUOTE |
Recently a class in a Catholic school tried to address the issue. Some students objected to the discussion, arguing that illegal immigration was wrong. They were asked to be quiet, and at the end one student changed, "White power" several times. |
International Level: International Guru / Political Participation: 1089 100%
I read it both ways. And I think the article contradicted itself. I will re-read it.
UPDATE
So do you get the view that:
* Spanish teacher asks why students need to learn Spanish
* Discussion turns to immigration
* 4 or 6 students (conflicts) voiced anti-immigration opinions (not sure if anti-immigration or anti-illegal immigration)
* 20 students remained silent or supported immigration
* 2 students were offended and asked to leave
* 1 student said, "White power" several times
* 1 student was disciplined
At first, I read it to mean that some students objected to the discussion as a whole, not on what was being said. I know that I would question the relevance of such a controversial topic in a class to learn Spanish.
Of course, the teacher didn't start the discussion in that manner. But it seems to have quickly gone the wrong way. Edited: tortdog on 31st Aug, 2007 - 4:57pm
First of all, yes, the article or versions contradict themselves. First it says:
QUOTE |
An e-mail sent to 9NEWS states the Hispanic students in the class at the time asked to leave, but were forced to stay in the classroom. |
QUOTE |
Two students, who were offended, asked to leave the classroom and were given permission to leave. |
International Level: International Guru / Political Participation: 1089 100%
My sister-in-law is Guatemalteca. A lady became angry at her in a parking lot, and the lady told her that she should to back to Mexico. My SIL was deeply offended, and responded, "I'm not from Mexico, I'm from Guatemala!"
I kind of laughed, because I doubt that the lady cared. But it was kind of funny since my SIL has little respect for Mexicans, viewing her own country as above them. Part of me was thinking that she had acted exactly as the other lady had, looking down at people from a certain country. Edited: tortdog on 31st Aug, 2007 - 5:34pm