Assuming it's done right, Japanese animation. I'm a big fan of the expressiveness it uses (just so long as it doesn't get too excessive). Character expressions and the overall look and feel tend to be better in my opinion. But, my main thing is the expressiveness. I mean, why else would I consider the following emoticon to be my favorite? ^_^
Yeah I am definitely a Japanese man! I love the way their eyes are drawn and all the emotion they can really put in to them! Plus they wear better clothes and have cooler character names
I don't have a preference for either style. They both have pluses and minuses, but, most of all, it is the individual story or plotline that interests me more than the animation style.
I also feel that 'western' animation gets a bad rap because most of what people see of it is meant for mindless entertainment while most of what we see of other countries' work is what was interesting enough to adults to have it brought here. Disney alone has put out a ton of great animation, some of which is every bit as detailed and deep as anime. If you ever want to see some classic, deep, slightly disturbing animation, dig up a copy of a movie called Wizards. It's animated and campy at times interspersed with very serious themes of the horror of warfare. The stand-out character is Necron-99, and he never does much more than tramp silently around wasting people until the very end (he's an assassin, what else would he do?). It's not intended for a young audience, like many of the anime shows that finally end up here. Oh, and there is plenty of fluff anime stuff, too (anyone remember Hello Kitty?). We just don't see it unless it's mass-marketable (the Japanese aren't stupid).
A review about Wizards
Another Review
Edited: Snerd on 18th Jan, 2005 - 8:42am
I prefer the Japanese style definitely. While Jap. style can get a little out of had with huge eyes and such, a lot of that style is much much more realistic. Look at Akira, Ghost in the Shell, and the series Witch Hunter Robin. The people look much more realistic then say Pokemon or Trigun. And they look a ton more realistic then Kids Next Door. The storylines, which tend to be more geared towards adults, are almost always more intricate and better woven together.
One of my favorite, Rurouni Kenshin, is a great example of this. An in depth character with a past, and it takes a good amount of the Series to find out what it is. The series progresses with his past catching up to him and the realization that one man can never out run his past, he can merely atone for it. I love the storyline, animation, and action scenes. It played a pivotal role in my love for Japanese animation.